Lake Calhoun shoot

A few weeks ago I built a miniature dock to use for lake scenes. Last evening Edwige and I finally got out to photograph it with our miniature fisherman and his dog. We shot a couple different scenes but I can't decide which image I like more. The first shot is pretty straight forward, as if I happened upon the scene and documented it with a "point and shoot" type camera (f/8.0). The second shot is a little more dreamy (f/4.5). The photos were shot 30 minutes apart and within a few feet of each other. 

If you have an opinion feel free to share by clicking on "comments".